ChatGPT Diagnoses Better Than Doctors? Here’s What It Means for Us All

• Who: Dr. Adam Rodman, internal medicine expert, and 50 U.S.-based physicians (residents and attending).

• What: A study comparing diagnostic accuracy between ChatGPT and doctors.

• When: Published recently in JAMA Network Open.

• Where: Large American hospital systems.

• Why: To test whether ChatGPT could assist in diagnosing medical cases.

Imagine a world where your doctor isn’t the smartest diagnostician in the room—but the chatbot on their laptop is. That world may already be here.

Picture this: A 76-year-old patient walks into a hospital. His symptoms puzzle the team of doctors. Meanwhile, an AI model analyzes the same case and delivers a near-perfect diagnosis.

This isn’t science fiction—it’s the future of healthcare. And it’s already happening.

In a groundbreaking study, Dr. Adam Rodman, a prominent internal medicine expert, tested whether ChatGPT-4 could assist doctors in diagnosing illnesses. What happened next shocked everyone: ChatGPT outperformed the doctors.

Source: https://www.nytimes.com/2024/11/17/health/chatgpt-ai-doctors-diagnosis.html#

In this experiment, 50 doctors tackled six challenging medical cases:

• Without AI: Doctors averaged a score of 74%.

• With AI Assistance: Their scores only improved slightly to 76%.

• AI Alone: ChatGPT scored a stunning 90%.

The shocking twist: The AI didn’t just provide accurate diagnoses—it outperformed its human counterparts in explaining its reasoning.

The chatbot didn’t just edge ahead—it leaped. It even aced the complex reasoning behind its diagnoses. So, what went wrong for the humans?

Despite having the perfect co-pilot, doctors in the study stuck to their own instincts, often disregarding the chatbot’s insights.

Dr. Rodman dug into chat logs and found two major issues

Researchers found two key reasons why AI outperformed the humans:

1. Overconfidence Bias

   • Doctors were often too sure of their initial diagnoses.

   • Even when AI flagged inconsistencies, many ignored them.

   • Laura Zwaan, a clinical reasoning expert, pointed out that “people generally overestimate their correctness.”

2. Underutilization

   • Instead of leveraging ChatGPT for full case analysis, many doctors treated it like a basic search engine.

   • Only a few realized they could copy-paste the entire case into the chatbot for comprehensive answers.

Did you know that efforts to create computer diagnosticians began 70 years ago?

One ambitious project, INTERNIST-1, launched in the 1970s with an impressive database of 500 diseases and 3,500 symptoms.

• The catch: It required hours of data input and wasn’t user-friendly.

• The result: Doctors didn’t trust it, and it faded into obscurity.

Fast-forward to today: ChatGPT’s language-processing capabilities and user-friendly interface are rewriting this narrative. But trust and training remain challenges.

After reviewing the chat logs, researchers discovered:

• Doctors often dismissed ChatGPT’s insights when they conflicted with their own.

• Many failed to ask the right questions, treating AI like a “Google search” rather than a collaborative partner.

• Those who engaged with the AI deeply uncovered its “smart and comprehensive” diagnostic abilities.

This isn’t just a wake-up call for doctors—it’s a lesson for anyone working alongside AI. The takeaway? To succeed, you need to:

• Embrace AI as a collaborative tool.

• Be open to questioning your assumptions.

• Learn to ask smarter questions and fully exploit AI’s potential.

Here’s your actionable playbook to integrate AI effectively in your work or life:

• Understand Your AI Tools: Spend time learning what your AI system can do beyond surface-level tasks.

• Think Beyond Search Engines: Instead of narrow queries, experiment with giving AI broader contexts or entire problem sets.

• Challenge Your Biases: Stay curious and open to alternatives—even when AI challenges your initial assumptions.

• Train Smarter Teams: Invest in training to help your team (or yourself) use AI as a true collaborator.

• Adopt a Beginner’s Mindset: AI excels when partnered with humility and willingness to learn.

"Technology amplifies human potential, but only if we learn how to use it."

What’s your take on AI’s role in decision-making? Are we ready to trust it, or is this just the beginning of a long journey? Let’s talk!

This post isn’t just about medicine—it’s about a shift in how we collaborate with machines across industries. Share it with someone who could benefit from seeing AI as more than just a tool!

1. Runway ML 🎨

   An AI toolkit offering multimodal capabilities, allowing artists to create videos, images, and soundscapes based on AI-generated content.

2. Stability AI 🌈

   The company behind tools like Stable Diffusion, enabling users to generate high-quality images from text prompts and multimodal interactions.

3. LegalMation ⚖️

   A legal AI that helps lawyers automate and streamline the process of reviewing and analyzing contracts, including multimodal data like scanned documents.

4. Synthesia 📽️

   A video generation platform that allows users to create high-quality videos by simply typing in text, with options to integrate voice and visual data.

5. Lumen5 🖼️

   An AI-powered video creation tool that turns blog posts, articles, or text into engaging multimedia content by combining text, images, and video.

1. 🧾 Social media users lack control over data used by AI, US FTC says

2. 🧾 No merger scrutiny of Microsoft's hiring of Inflection staff, EU says

3. 🧾 Finnish politician tapped as EU digital chief to oversee big tech

4. 🧾 The Chinese chipmaker at the heart of the US-China tech war

5. 🧾 90% of financial institutions focusing on AI, GenAI for innovation: PwC India report

Empower Your Journey With Generative AI.

"You're at the forefront of innovation. Dive into a world where AI isn't just a tool, but a transformative journey. Whether you're a budding entrepreneur, a seasoned professional, or a curious learner, we're here to guide you."

Think Ahead With AI is more than just a platform.

Founded with a vision to democratize Generative AI knowledge,

It's a movement.

It’s a commitment.

It’s a promise to bring AI within everyone's reach.

Together, we explore, innovate, and transform.

Our mission is to help marketers, coaches, professionals and business owners integrate Generative AI and use artificial intelligence to skyrocket their careers and businesses. 🚀

Joydeep Rakshit
Gen. AI Explorer
Co-Founder, Think Ahead With AI (TAWAI)